Secrets Wild Orchid vs. Secrets St. James

If you’re planning a romantic getaway or a special celebration like a honeymoon, anniversary, or destination wedding, a Secrets Resort in Jamaica is an excellent choice. With two beautiful adults-only all-inclusive resorts located side by side–Secrets Wild Orchid and Secrets St. James–you’ll have an unforgettable vacation.

In this comprehensive comparison of each Secrets Resort in Jamaica: Wild Orchid vs. St James, we’ll dive into the unique features of each resort, helping you make an informed decision for your dream vacation.

Secrets Resort Jamaica: Wild Orchid vs. St. James Overview

Both Secrets Wild Orchid and Secrets St. James are adults-only, all-inclusive resorts conveniently located on a picturesque peninsula in Montego Bay, Jamaica. This prime location offers seclusion and tranquility while still being just a short transfer from the Montego Bay airport.

The resorts are situated at the end of the peninsula and surrounded by a gated community, ensuring privacy and exclusivity for guests. This also means that you won’t encounter local vendors on the beaches, allowing for a peaceful and uninterrupted beach experience.

However, if you want to venture off of the resort to experience the local culture and take a tour, you can easily do so, as transportation is readily available. You can either arrange transportation with the resort or book a van or taxi online. The other option is to rent a car, which will give you the most freedom when exploring the island.

What Are Secrets Resorts Known For?

As a whole, Secrets resorts are known for being a luxurious adults-only all-inclusive experience. You’ll find couples in a mix of age ranges enjoying a romantic getaway, honeymoon, or destination wedding.

Secrets Resort Jamaica: Wild Orchid vs. St. James Accommodations

The accommodations at each Secrets resort in Jamaica are designed with luxury and comfort in mind. From the standard Junior Suites to the opulent Preferred Club Master Suites, there is a room category to suit every preference. The Preferred Club rooms offer additional amenities such as private check-in/check-out service, a private concierge, and access to a private pool.

The suites boast spacious living areas, whirlpool tubs, Smart TVs, and private balconies with stunning views. Whether you choose a garden view, ocean view, or oceanfront room, you can expect well-appointed and modern accommodations.

In general, the rooms at the two Secrets resorts are similar but have slightly different decor. Secrets St. James rooms have a blend of a British Colonial vibe with a navy blue color scheme. Secrets Wild Orchid rooms have a tropic feel with light neutral colors that compliment the Caribbean Island.

Secrets Resort Jamaica: Wild Orchid vs. St. James Beaches and Pools

These two Secrets resorts in Jamaica boast three beautiful beaches, each offering a unique atmosphere. The beach in front of Secrets St. James is quieter and more secluded, perfect for those seeking relaxation and tranquility. The largest beach in front of Secrets Wild Orchid is livelier, with jerk carts and fruit vendors during lunchtime.

It is also conveniently located near several lunch restaurants and the main pool area. The third beach, accessible to Preferred Club guests, offers upgraded lounge chairs and a more exclusive experience. Whichever beach you choose, you can expect pristine sands and turquoise waters.

In terms of pools, there are four stunning options. The two larger pools are open to all guests and provide the perfect setting for relaxation or enjoying the lively atmosphere. The two pools reserved for Preferred Club guests offer upgraded lounge chairs and a more serene environment. Whether you prefer a more peaceful poolside experience or a vibrant party atmosphere, each Secrets resort in Jamaica has you covered.

Secrets Resort Jamaica: Wild Orchid vs. St. James Dining and Drinking

One of the highlights of Secrets resorts are their exceptional dining options. With numerous gourmet restaurants and bars, you’ll have a wide variety of cuisines and flavors to choose from. From traditional Jamaican and Caribbean dishes to contemporary French, Mexican, Italian, and Pan-Asian specialties, there is something to satisfy every palate. The all-inclusive nature of the resorts means that you can indulge in unlimited dining and premium drinks throughout your stay.

For casual dining, you can visit the Barefoot Grill or the Seaside Grill, offering grilled specialties with a beachside ambiance. If you’re in the mood for Jamaican and Caribbean cuisine, head to the Blue Mountain restaurant. For a taste of French elegance, Bordeaux will delight your taste buds with its contemporary French dishes.

Other options include El Patio (Mexican cuisine), Himitsu (Pan-Asian specialties), Oceana (seafood), Portofino (Italian trattoria-style), and the World Cafe (international buffet). Each resort also features various bars and lounges, ensuring you’re never far from a refreshing drink or a cozy spot to enjoy some evening entertainment.

Secrets Resort Jamaica: Wild Orchid vs. St. James Entertainment and Activities

There is no shortage of entertainment and activities to keep you engaged throughout your stay. An outdoor amphitheater hosts nightly shows, including live music performances and exciting acrobatic acts. After dinner, you can easily transition from one of the fine dining restaurants to the amphitheater for a memorable evening of entertainment.

If you’re looking for relaxation and rejuvenation, the Spa by Pevonia is the perfect place to unwind. Located at Secrets St. James, the spa offers a complete hydrotherapy circuit, which can be enjoyed as a standalone experience or as part of a spa treatment. Indulge in a couples’ massage and escape to a serene private enclave where you can unwind side by side.

Secrets Resort Jamaica: Wild Orchid vs. St. James How to Choose

Really, there isn’t much difference between these two Jamaica Secrets resorts. Both are located on the peninsula with picturesque views of the Caribbean Sea. Plus, both include a small beach area. And regardless of where you stay, you can visit either resort to enjoy all the amenities and facilities.

However, you will have closer access to the restaurants, entertainment, and bars at Secrets Wild Orchid. If you would rather be closer to the spa and gym, then St. James is a better choice. Since both resorts’ locations are on a peninsula, they offer a sense of privacy and the convenience of easy access between Wild Orchid and St. James. If you decide to book a Preferred Club room, It will grant access to a third resort, Breathless, creating a truly unique experience.

Secrets Resort Jamaica: Wild Orchid vs. St. James Conclusion

In conclusion, both Secrets Wild Orchid and Secrets St. James offer an exceptional experience for adults seeking a romantic and luxurious getaway in Jamaica. Whether you prefer a livelier atmosphere with access to a range of restaurants and the main pool area (Secrets Wild Orchid) or a quieter and more secluded beach experience (Secrets St. James), both Secrets Jamaica resorts provide a wealth of amenities, top-notch service, and an unforgettable vacation.

The choice ultimately depends on your personal preferences and the type of ambiance you desire. Overall, you can’t go wrong with either resort since they are a hop and skip away from each other. If you book on one side, you can easily make a quick trip to the other side and explore different options. No matter which you choose, either Secrets resort in Jamaica is sure to make your vacation one-of-a-kind.

Not sure which Secrets resort to choose for your next vacation? These articles might help, including Secrets Resorts Locations 2023, Cheapest Secrets Resort for an Affordable All-Inclusive Adults-Only Vacation, 5 Best Secrets Resorts in Mexico 2023,10 Best Secrets Resorts in 2023, Secrets Papagayo Costa Rica Reviews 2023, and Secrets vs. Sandals: Which Adults-Only All-Inclusive Resort Is Best for You?.

Ready to get started?

Get the help of a seasoned travel advisor. We'll help you make the best choice for your vacation, guide you through the travel planning process, and support you until you are back home.

Working with a travel advisor

You don't know what you don't know

We visit the resorts we recommend regularly, leveraging our unbiased expertise to meet or exceed your expectations. From round-trip airfare and transfers to accommodations at top-notch resorts, we handle it all. Let us be your trusted travel partner, aiming not just for a single sale but a lasting relationship.

There are so many details we work through seamlessly because we do this every day and know how to work everything out to give you an amazing experience.

Don't waste any more time researching online when you can talk to an expert

Our travel experts are here to help you plan the perfect vacation. With over 20 years of experience in all-inclusive travel, we customize vacations to suit your preferences, ensuring competitive pricing.

  • We provide personalized customer service to guide you before, during, and after your trip. We handle issues directly, avoiding large, impersonal call centers.
  • We'll match or beat any legitimate quote.
  • We have access to the best prices, promotions, and possible rate adjustments if resort prices drop after your down payment.
  • Our relationships and connections in travel allow our clients to get upgrades and perks at the resorts they stay at.

What people say about us

We worked with Mike to plan our perfect honeymoon in Greece — he was amazing the whole way through and put together a trip we will cherish for our lifetime.

He was thoughtful with our suggestions, and provided some of his own without every pushing us. He stayed within our budgetary means but made it feel like we had a budget twice the size. 


Dan and Michelle were such a joy to work with! They really made our trip and cruise successful. Based on our needs they were able to help us identify and schedule what side trips and activities would best suit our interests.

After this trip I will be using a travel agent for future vacations…just can’t wait for the next one they help us plan!


Honeymoon Always has been fantastic- our trips were 1000% better because of their help. The first time we used them we wanted to have a fun trip with some cultural experiences, good food, not too packed, and for a good price. It was fantastic and now we've used them for several trips in Europe, Central America, and the Caribbean. Each trip was so different but they were able to make each one special and unique to our needs.


Get In Touch

"*" indicates required fields

Let us know if you have a destination, activities, dates in mind or anything else that will help us serve you.

Leave a Comment